81 Lawsuit Claims Construction To Have Negative Impact On Environment 81 Lawsuit Claims Construction To Have Negative Environmental Impact

Syracuse, New York — Construction On The I-81 construction project has been halted.

A state judge halted development on the I-81 project in Syracuse last month after a host of law suits have been filed in opposition to the project.

The group behind the lawsuit, Renew 81 For All, opposes the project’s “community grid” the group cites a multitude of factors behind the lawsuit. Supporters of the  I-81 Construction project claim the lawsuits are to delay development and stop the project all together.

Though signees on the suit say otherwise, Charles Garland a Democratic legislator on the Onondaga Legislature says that the suit is more about the environmental impact.

“Its not about keeping it or you know anything like that. Its about the fact that NYSDOT did
not do the environmental justice testing that they would require of any other contractor.” Garland said.

The suit, filed by the firm Knauf Shaw LLP out of Rochester. States that the I-81 Project does not comply with the State Environmental Quality Review Act (EEQRA) as well as other state environmental regulations. The suit also claims that the redirect of traffic will impact surrounding communities with pollution. Which Garland believes will impact the African American communities the hardest.

“They’re going to redirect those same overhead emissions from traffic right back into the African
American Area.” Garland Said.

While these suits are occurring Garland believes that 81 needs to be rebuilt and that the current structure is out of date. The proposal he supports is the Harriet Tubman Memorial Freedom Bridge. The proposed Skybridge would be a rebuilt of the current 81 bridge and would be 70 feet in the air. Garland says it would provide Syracuse with what the current bridge does now with traffic.

“I-81 might have outlived its structural use but not its functional use and thats the like of conveying the traffic through, so it was a wonderful idea.” Garland Said.

The first hearing in the New York Supreme Court will be on January 12th, 2023.

 

JACOB BERNARDINI: LAST MONTH A STATE JUDGE STOPPED THE START OF CONSTRUCTION ON THE
I-81 PROJECT IN SYRACUSE THAT WOULD FUNDAMENTALY CHANGE HOW TRAFFIC
FLOWS IN THE CITY. THE GROUP BEHIND THE DELAY, RENEW 81 FOR ALL, HAS
BEEN CRITICIZED FOR THEIR EFFORTS BEING FRIVOLOUS AND ATTEMPTING TO
STOP THE PROJECT. ONE OF THE GROUPS SIGNEES IS ONONDAGA COUNTY
LEGISLATOR CHARLES GARLAND, WHO OWNS GARLAND BROTHERS FUNERAL
HOME JUST OFF OF THE HIGHWAY, HE CLAIMS THAT IS A MISCONCEPTION AND
THAT ITS REALLY ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT.

CHARLES GARLAND: ITS NOT ABOUT KEEPING IT OR YOU KNOW ANYTHING LIKE THAT. ITS ABOUT THE FACT THAT NYSDOT DID NOT DO THE ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE TESTING THAT THEY WOULD REQUIRE OF ANY OTHER CONTRACTOR.

BERNARDINI: IN THEIR LAWSUIT, RENEW 81 FOR ALL CLAIMED THAT THE I-81 PROJECT DID NOT COMPLY WITH THE STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT AND THAT THE REVIEW SHOULD HAVE BEEN MORE RIGOROUS. GARLAND ALSO CLAIMS THAT THE
PROPOSED BUSINESS LOOP 81 WOULD NEGATIVELY IMPACT POLLUTION IN THE
SURROUNDING AREA.

GARLAND: THEY’RE GOING TO REDIRECT THOSE SAME OVERHEARD TAXEMES IN TRAFFIC RIGHT BACK INTO THE AFRICAN AMERICAN AREA.”

BERNARDINI DESPITE GARLANDS OBJECTIONS HE BELIEVES THAT PROGRESS IS NECESSARY AND THAT 81 IN ITS CURRENT FORM IS NOT SUSTAINABLE. ONE ALTERNATIVE HE SUPPORTS IS THE HARRIET TUBMAN MEMORIAL FREEDOM BRIDGE, A BRIDGE
BUILT IN THE PLACE OF 81 THAT WOULD BE 70 FEET TALL AND WOULD ALLOW FOR
A GRID UNDERNEATH. GARLAND SAYS THE IDEA WOULD BE BENEFICIAL TO 81’s
CURRENT USE FOR TRAFFIC FLOW.

GARLAND: I-81 MIGHT HAVE OUTLIVED ITS STRUCTURAL USE BUT NOT ITS FUNCTIONAL USE AND THATS THE LIKE OF CONVEYING THE TRAFFIC THROUGH, SO IT WAS A WONDERFUL IDEA.

BERNARDINI THE HEARING FOR THE CASE IS SET TO TAKE PLACE IN THE NEW YORK SUPREME
COURT ON JANUARY 12TH OF 20-23. A CASE THAT COULD DECIDE THE FUTURE
FOR I-81 CONSTRUCTION IN SYRACUSE MAY LASR FOR A WHILE. JACOB
BERNARDINI N-C-C NEWS

Related Articles